Report: Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million Palestinian photos to Amazon AI tool

By

Leaked documents show the Israeli military moved 3.5 million images into Amazon's cloud in early 2024 to analyse Palestinians with its Rekognition facial recognition platform. AWS says it has no "visibility" into what customers keep in its cloud.

Report: Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million Palestinian photos to Amazon AI tool
Photo: Al Jazeera English
Key numbers in the Amazon files story
3.5 Photos uploaded (million)
2,021 Year of Project Nimbus contract
2,024 Year of upload notice to Amazon
Source: The Guardian

The Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million photos to Amazon’s cloud platform so it could run the US company’s facial recognition technology on images of Palestinians, the Guardian reported on Monday, citing leaked documents and interviews with military sources. The images were moved into Amazon’s cloud in the early months of Israel’s bombardment and ground offensive in Gaza.

The upload came from a department commonly known as Rolling Stone, part of a military software unit. It takes its name from a system the military uses as a central store of information about Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. In early 2024 the department told Amazon it would upload the images to use Rekognition, the company’s AI-powered image analysis platform, for a facial recognition project. The photos went to an Amazon datacentre near Tel Aviv.

After the ground invasion of Gaza in October 2023, the military routinely photographed Palestinians as they passed through checkpoints, often after the bombing had driven them from their homes. It is not clear whether the 3.5 million images came from these checkpoints. However, a military source familiar with the facial recognition work there said Amazon’s cloud was used because of the “very large scale” of the images collected. In early 2024 a small group of Israeli soldiers also worked from AWS’s Tel Aviv offices, exploring ways to run a facial recognition programme in Gaza more effectively, several military sources said.

An AWS spokesperson said the company had no “visibility” into workloads its customers hold in its cloud and does not discuss customer relationships without their consent. Asked about the soldiers working from its offices, the spokesperson said customers “regularly visit our offices for briefings and meetings” and that any suggestion the visits were anything other than routine customer engagement was “wrong and unsubstantiated”.

Israel has long used facial recognition, especially in the occupied West Bank, where face scanning is routine at checkpoints and soldiers collect images with custom-built smartphone apps. Early in the Gaza campaign, the military used Rekognition to identify hostages taken in the Hamas-led attack of October 7, 2023, and deployed facial recognition to identify suspected militants. The New York Times has previously reported that the military’s tests of commercial technology in Gaza at times wrongly flagged civilians as militants.

The ties rest on Project Nimbus, a multibillion-dollar 2021 contract under which AWS and Google provide cloud services to Israeli government and military clients. Details revealed last year show the contract bars the US companies from restricting or suspending Israeli use of their services, even if Israel breaches their terms of service. That clause would rule out the kind of step Microsoft took last year, when it cut the Israeli military’s access to technology used to run a mass surveillance system.

The documents cover a period in which Israel has been accused of grave crimes in Gaza, including genocide. Israel denies the charge, which is supported by a UN commission of inquiry, Israeli human rights groups and genocide experts.

Fiji Tanzania Western Sahara Canada United States Kazakhstan Uzbekistan Papua New Guinea Indonesia Argentina Chile Congo - Kinshasa Somalia Kenya Sudan Chad Haiti Dominican Republic Russia Bahamas Falkland Islands Norway Greenland French Southern Territories Timor-Leste South Africa Lesotho Mexico Uruguay Brazil Bolivia Peru Colombia Panama Costa Rica Nicaragua Honduras El Salvador Guatemala Belize Venezuela Guyana Suriname France Ecuador Puerto Rico Jamaica Cuba Zimbabwe Botswana Namibia Senegal Mali Mauritania Benin Niger Nigeria Cameroon Togo Ghana Côte d’Ivoire Guinea Guinea-Bissau Liberia Sierra Leone Burkina Faso Central African Republic Congo - Brazzaville Gabon Equatorial Guinea Zambia Malawi Mozambique Swaziland Angola Burundi Israel Lebanon Madagascar Palestinian Territories Gambia Tunisia Algeria Jordan United Arab Emirates Qatar Kuwait Iraq Oman Vanuatu Cambodia Thailand Laos Myanmar (Burma) Vietnam North Korea South Korea Mongolia India Bangladesh Bhutan Nepal Pakistan Afghanistan Tajikistan Kyrgyzstan Turkmenistan Iran Syria Armenia Sweden Belarus Ukraine Poland Austria Hungary Moldova Romania Lithuania Latvia Estonia Germany Bulgaria Greece Turkey Albania Croatia Switzerland Luxembourg Belgium Netherlands Portugal Spain Ireland New Caledonia Solomon Islands New Zealand Australia Sri Lanka China Taiwan Italy Denmark United Kingdom Iceland Azerbaijan Georgia Philippines Malaysia Brunei Slovenia Finland Slovakia Czechia Eritrea Japan Paraguay Yemen Saudi Arabia N. Cyprus Cyprus Morocco Egypt Libya Ethiopia Djibouti Somaliland Uganda Rwanda Bosnia & Herzegovina Macedonia Serbia Montenegro Kosovo Trinidad & Tobago South Sudan Israel Palestinian Territories United States
Israel, Palestinian Territories, United States

Sources The Guardian

Back to 17 November