Costa Rica’s Grynspan leads UN chief race but faces possible US, Russia veto

By

Costa Rican diplomat Rebeca Grynspan won 12 "encourage" votes in the Security Council's November 5 straw poll, PassBlue reported. Eight candidates are vying to replace Antonio Guterres, who must leave office on December 31.

Security Council straw poll, November 5
  • Encourage
  • Discourage
0 4 8 12
12 3
9 4
GrynspanGrossi
Source: PassBlue, via Al Jazeera English; story text says latest poll was November 5 ('e
Table
EncourageDiscourage
Grynspan123
Grossi94

The race to pick the next United Nations Secretary-General is entering its final weeks with no clear winner, Al Jazeera reported. Eight candidates are still in the running. Antonio Guterres must leave office on December 31, a deadline that has never been missed. That raises fears that, for the first time, the new year could begin with no one leading the UN.

Rebeca Grynspan, the Costa Rican head of the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), leads the Security Council's secret straw polls. In the latest poll on November 5, she won 12 "encourage" votes and three "discourage" votes, according to PassBlue, a nonprofit that covers the UN. The poll does not show how each council member voted. Rafael Grossi, the Argentinian head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, came second with nine "encourage" and four "discourage" votes.

To win, a candidate needs at least nine votes in the 15-member Security Council and no veto from its five permanent members: the US, the UK, France, Russia and China. The 193-member General Assembly must then approve the choice. Two late entries, Emirati diplomat Lana Nusseibeh and Turkish nominee Feridun Sinirlioglu, have blown the race further open. Five of the eight candidates are women, and most come from Latin America or the Caribbean.

Richard Gowan of the International Crisis Group told Al Jazeera that Grynspan has become the frontrunner. But she still appears to face opposition from Washington and Moscow. Some of her UNCTAD reports raised concerns about Israel's actions in Gaza and the occupied West Bank. She has also disagreed with Russia's reasons for suspending the Black Sea grain deal. Gowan said US officials seem to be leaving open the possibility of working with her. Grynspan met Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in April to discuss her bid.

Grossi's reputation for being close to Washington is expected to hurt him with China and Russia, Al Jazeera reported. Still, he has recently spoken warmly about Beijing and Moscow. Ben Donaldson of the 1 for 8 Billion campaign said opposition in a straw poll does not always lead to a veto. He said permanent members have used such opposition in the past to extract backroom deals, often a senior UN post for one of their nationals.

The contest comes at a hard time for the UN. The organisation has been sidelined from the conflicts in Iran and Ukraine and criticised by US President Donald Trump. A financial crisis has forced it to let go of thousands of staff. Georgina Holmes of the Open University said the permanent members are less politically aligned now than in previous eras, "arguably even during the Cold War".

Fiji Tanzania Western Sahara Canada United States Kazakhstan Uzbekistan Papua New Guinea Indonesia Argentina Chile Congo - Kinshasa Somalia Kenya Sudan Chad Haiti Dominican Republic Russia Bahamas Falkland Islands Norway Greenland French Southern Territories Timor-Leste South Africa Lesotho Mexico Uruguay Brazil Bolivia Peru Colombia Panama Costa Rica Nicaragua Honduras El Salvador Guatemala Belize Venezuela Guyana Suriname France Ecuador Puerto Rico Jamaica Cuba Zimbabwe Botswana Namibia Senegal Mali Mauritania Benin Niger Nigeria Cameroon Togo Ghana Côte d’Ivoire Guinea Guinea-Bissau Liberia Sierra Leone Burkina Faso Central African Republic Congo - Brazzaville Gabon Equatorial Guinea Zambia Malawi Mozambique Swaziland Angola Burundi Israel Lebanon Madagascar Palestinian Territories Gambia Tunisia Algeria Jordan United Arab Emirates Qatar Kuwait Iraq Oman Vanuatu Cambodia Thailand Laos Myanmar (Burma) Vietnam North Korea South Korea Mongolia India Bangladesh Bhutan Nepal Pakistan Afghanistan Tajikistan Kyrgyzstan Turkmenistan Iran Syria Armenia Sweden Belarus Ukraine Poland Austria Hungary Moldova Romania Lithuania Latvia Estonia Germany Bulgaria Greece Turkey Albania Croatia Switzerland Luxembourg Belgium Netherlands Portugal Spain Ireland New Caledonia Solomon Islands New Zealand Australia Sri Lanka China Taiwan Italy Denmark United Kingdom Iceland Azerbaijan Georgia Philippines Malaysia Brunei Slovenia Finland Slovakia Czechia Eritrea Japan Paraguay Yemen Saudi Arabia N. Cyprus Cyprus Morocco Egypt Libya Ethiopia Djibouti Somaliland Uganda Rwanda Bosnia & Herzegovina Macedonia Serbia Montenegro Kosovo Trinidad & Tobago South Sudan Costa Rica United States Russia Argentina China Turkey
Costa Rica, United States, Russia, Argentina, China, Turkey

Sources Al Jazeera English

Back to 16 November